My Cart

Secrets for the Best Homemade Ice Cream Sandwich

Summertime is here, and so are the days of ice cream sandwiches on a sunny day. While they’re easy to buy, you can easily create even more unique homemade ice cream sandwiches that are made to your personal tastes. Mix-and-match ice cream flavors, cookie types (or other sandwich bases), and toppings for something that friends and family will love. And the fun doesn’t end with cookie ice cream sandwiches when there are so many other alternatives to try! This summer treat is a favorite among children and adults alike, and with our comprehensive guide, you'll soon be able to create your own scrumptious versions at home.


Table of Contents:

  • What are the best homemade cookies for ice cream sandwiches?
  • Homemade Ice Cream Made Easy
  • Creative Cookie & Ice Cream Pairings
  • Assembling Your Masterpiece
  • Proper Storage Techniques
  • FAQs in Relation to Best Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches
  • Conclusion


What Are the Best Homemade Cookies for Ice Cream Sandwiches?

Array of ice cream sandwiches

Picking the perfect cookie to complement your chosen ice cream flavor is crucial. Classic options include chocolate chip or sugar cookies paired with vanilla ice cream. For something more adventurous, try ginger snaps with pumpkin spice ice cream or oatmeal raisin cookies alongside caramel swirl.

The real key to the best cookie for an ice cream sandwich? The texture.


Baking Tips to Achieve Desired Texture
  • Crispy: Bake at a higher temperature (375°F) for a shorter time (8-10 minutes).
  • Chewy: Use brown sugar instead of white sugar in your recipe; bake at 350°F for about 12 minutes.
  • Cakey: Add an extra egg yolk to your dough; bake at 325°F until edges are golden brown (~15 minutes).

No matter which type you choose, remember that homemade cookies should be slightly under-baked so they remain soft after freezing. This will ensure every bite of your homemade ice cream sandwich is scrumptious.


Homemade Ice Cream Made Easy

Elevate your ice cream sandwiches by making homemade ice cream using simple recipes like no-churn strawberry ice cream. This allows you to control ingredients and flavors while ensuring every bite is delectable. Plus, with no-churn recipes, you don’t even need an ice cream maker. You can even use a blend-and-freeze ice cream mix like Hijinx, that you simply blend with your favorite ingredients, then freeze.


How-to Guide for Creating No-Churn or Churned Versions

No-Churn: For an easy, no-fuss method of making homemade ice cream, try the popular no-churn technique. To craft a no-churn ice cream, one needs to procure heavy whipping cream, condensed milk with sugar added in, vanilla extract (or any other flavoring), and any additional mix-ins like mini chocolate chips or chopped nuts. Whip the heavy cream until stiff peaks form, then fold in the sweetened condensed milk and flavoring. Pour into a freezer-safe container, add mix-ins if desired, and freeze for at least 6 hours.

Churned: If you have an ice cream maker at home, churned ice cream is another delicious option. Simply follow your favorite ice cream recipe, pour it into the machine's bowl according to manufacturer instructions, and let it do its magic.


What Kind of Ice Cream is Used in Ice Cream Sandwiches?

Vanilla is the traditional ice cream used in ice cream sandwiches. But there are a few others that often pair well with the traditional chocolate cookie sandwich:

  • Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Chocolate Ice Cream
  • Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
  • Coffee-flavored ice creams: Try pairing with mint chip cookies or chocolate brownies.

But the fun of homemade ice cream sandwiches, is that you can create more unusual pairings than you’d normally find in stores...


Creative Cookie & Ice Cream Pairings

Couple of ice cream sandwiches

When it comes to creating the best homemade ice cream sandwich, there are endless possibilities for cookie pairings and add-ons that complement each other perfectly. From mint chip cookies (imagine a Thin Mint ice cream sandwich) paired with coffee-flavored ice cream to strawberry sugar cookies combined with classic vanilla bean, the options are limitless.

When you create your own ice cream, you can truly expand the flavor combinations into infinity. Learn more about pairing ice cream with cookies here.

Gluten-Free Options for Inclusive Dessert Enjoyment

Don't let dietary restrictions hold you back from enjoying a delicious homemade ice cream sandwich. For those with dietary restrictions, a gluten-free alternative such as gluten-free chocolate chip cookies can be used to create an inclusive dessert experience.


Unique Out-of-the-Box Ideas like Waffle-wiches
  • Mix-and-Match: Combine different types of cookies or use unconventional bases like brownies, waffles, or rice crispy treats for a unique twist on the traditional ice cream sandwich.
  • Sweet and Savory: Try adding salty elements such as pretzels or potato chips to contrast against the sweetness of your homemade ice cream.
  • Fruit-Filled Delights: Incorporate fresh fruit pieces or fruit-based sauces into your sandwiches for added flavor complexity. For example, try this mouthwatering combination: mini chocolate chips + chopped nuts + vanilla ice cream + raspberry sauce = heaven.


Assembling Your Masterpiece

Funfetti ice cream cookie sandwich

Now that your ideal cookie base and homemade ice cream are all ready, it's time to bring them together for the ultimate summer treat.

  1. Begin by placing a scoop of vanilla ice cream (or any flavor of your choice) onto the flat side of one cookie.
  2. Gently press another cookie on top to create a sandwich.
  3. If desired, roll the edges in mini chocolate chips or chopped nuts for added texture and flavor.


Tips for Achieving the Perfect Consistency During the Assembly Process
  • To prevent the ice cream from melting too quickly, work in small batches and keep the remaining cookies and ice cream in the freezer until needed. Cookies will return to their chewy consistency once defrosted.
  • If desired, use an offset spatula or butter knife to smooth out the edges for a more polished look.


Ideas for Kid-Friendly Decorating Activities

Add some excitement to your homemade ice cream sandwiches with fun decorations. On a baking sheet, roll the exposed edges of each sandwich through toppings like mini chocolate chips, sprinkles, or chopped nuts. You can even get creative with crushed potato chips or caramel swirls inside the filling itself.

Allow assembled sandwiches to sit at room temperature briefly so that decorations adhere easily. Once decorated, wrap each portion individually in plastic wrap or beeswax food wraps before storing them overnight in an airtight freezer bag. This will ensure they're ready for enjoyment whenever you please.


Proper Storage Techniques

Ice cream sandwich with packaging

Now that you've created your scrumptious homemade ice cream sandwiches, it's essential to store them properly for optimal enjoyment. By following these simple storage techniques, you can keep your frozen treats fresh and delicious for up to three months without losing quality, taste, or texture.


Ensuring Freshness While Maintaining Perfect Consistency
  • Wrap individual portions: Use plastic wrap or eco-friendly alternatives like beeswax food wraps, ensuring each sandwich is completely covered. This will help maintain their shape and prevent freezer burn.
  • Airtight container: Place the wrapped portions in a large freezer bag or an airtight container to further protect them from moisture and potential odors in the freezer.
  • Date & label: Don't forget to write down the date of preparation on each package so you know when they were made.


Tips on Thawing and Serving for Optimal Enjoyment

To ensure maximum flavor and perfect consistency when serving your homemade ice cream sandwiches, follow these quick tips:

  1. Gently thaw at room temperature: About ten minutes before enjoying your tasty creation, remove it from the freezer and let it sit at room temperature briefly. This allows the cookies to soften slightly while maintaining their integrity.
  2. Serve with extras: If desired, serve alongside additional toppings such as mini chocolate chips or chopped nuts for added crunchiness.

Your guests will be delighted not only by how amazing these homemade ice cream sandwiches taste, but also by the care and attention you've put into their presentation. Happy indulging.


FAQs in Relation to Best Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches


What ingredients do you need to make the best homemade ice cream sandwiches?

To make the best homemade ice cream sandwiches, you'll need high-quality ingredients for your cookie dough, such as all-purpose flour, unsalted butter, granulated sugar, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, and baking soda. Additionally, choose a premium ice cream flavor (store bought ice cream or homemade).


How long does it take to prepare and cook homemade ice cream sandwiches?

The preparation time for making homemade ice cream sandwiches varies depending on factors like chilling the dough and cooling cookies after baking. Generally speaking though, expect around 30 minutes of active prep time plus 10-12 minutes of cooking time per batch.


What is the best way to store homemade ice cream sandwiches?

The ideal method for storing homemade ice cream sandwiches is in an airtight container in the freezer. Place parchment paper between each sandwich to prevent sticking. For optimal freshness and texture consistency, store them at -18°C (0°F) for up to three months.


Are there any special tips for making delicious homemade ice cream sandwiches?

Achieving perfect consistency throughout requires attention to detail: cool cookies completely before assembly; use slightly softened but not melted ice cream; press down gently when assembling; freeze assembled treats immediately.


What are some creative ideas for customizing your own unique homemade ice cream sandwich recipe?
  • Experiment with gluten-free cookie recipes.
  • Try a wafflewich using homemade waffles instead of cookies.
  • Add gourmet toppings like chopped nuts, mini chocolate chips, or fruit compote.



Crafting the ultimate DIY ice cream sandwiches is a great way to wow your family and friends with delectable delights. Making the best homemade ice cream sandwiches can be low-stress and high-creativity. With so many options available, from classic vanilla with chocolate chip cookies to more adventurous flavors like lavender honey with shortbread cookies, there's something for everyone! So why not try making your own today?

Ready to take on this sweet challenge? Check out Hijinx Ice Cream, where they the EASIEST way to elevate your homemade ice cream sandwich game with custom homemade ice cream!



Leave your comment