My Cart

How to Make Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream

Now, your favorite baked goods can be enjoyed in ice cream form, as lemon poppy seed ice cream! If you've ever savored a lemon poppy seed muffin, then the thought of transforming those delightful flavors into an ice cream will surely tantalize your taste buds. Read on for a detailed recipe for easy, homemade lemon poppy seed ice cream, complete with all ingredients needed and step-by-step instructions using an ice cream maker. Plus, a recipe for an even easier no-churn version.


Table of Contents:

  • The Unique Flavor Pairing of Lemon and Poppy Seed
  • Recipe for Homemade Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream (Ice Cream Maker)
  • No-Churn Recipe for Homemade Lemon Poppy seed ice cream
  • Poppy Seeds: To Soak or Not to Soak?
  • Creative Serving Suggestions For Your Homemade Ice Cream
  • Commercial Success Stories Featuring Similar Flavors
  • Alternative Ingredient Options for Vegan Ice Cream
  • FAQs in Relation to Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream
  • Conclusion


The Unique Flavor Pairing of Lemon and Poppy Seed

Lemon poppy seed bread loaf

Lemon poppy seed ice cream is a complementary blend that combines the tartness of lemon with the subtle crunchiness of poppy seeds. This innovative flavor pairing offers a balance between creamy sweetness and citrusy lemon zest, making it perfect for those who crave fruit-flavored frozen desserts.

What Flavor is “Poppy”?

Poppy seeds, despite their small size, pack in a nutty flavor along with a pleasing crunch that adds texture to every scoop. Meanwhile, the tangy freshness of lemon juice provides an invigorating contrast to the rich creaminess typically associated with ice creams.

How this unique combination enhances your dessert experience
  • Sweet vs Sour: The sweet base from sugar or honey combined with sour lemons creates an exciting play on your palate.
  • Creamy vs Crunchy: The smooth consistency contrasts beautifully against crunchy sprinkles of poppy seeds scattered throughout each bite.
  • Rich vs Refreshing: While traditional ice cream can be heavy, adding zesty lemons lightens up its richness making it more refreshing during hot summer days.

This fusion not only results in an unexpected yet harmonious symphony but also takes you on an exciting gastronomic journey where classic meets unconventional. So next time when you're looking for something different than vanilla or chocolate - consider giving this enticing combo a try.


Recipe for Homemade Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream (Ice Cream Maker)

Lemon poppy seed ice cream in a cone

Photo Credit: Yes to Yolks

If you're a fan of unique and refreshing flavors, then this homemade lemon poppy seed ice cream recipe is perfect for you. This dessert offers a wonderful balance between creamy sweetness and citrusy zest.


  • 1 cup sugar
  • Zest and juice of 4 lemons
  • 6 egg yolks (tempered)
  • 1 pint heavy cream
  • 1/2 cup whole milk
  • A pinch of salt
  • 2 tablespoons honey
  • 2 tablespoons poppy seeds

The star ingredients here are the fresh lemons and crunchy poppy seeds which give our ice cream its distinctive flavor profile.

Recipe for homemade lemon poppy seed ice cream:

  1. In a medium saucepan, combine the sugar with the lemon zest and lemon juice. Stir until well combined.
  2. Slowly add in your tempered egg yolks while whisking continuously to avoid curdling or scrambling them.
  3. Add in your heavy cream, whole milk, salt, honey, and poppy seeds. Mix together thoroughly. This will be your ice cream base.
  4. Churn the mixture according to your ice cream maker's instructions.
  5. Transfer the mixture to an air-tight container and place in the freezer for a minimum of 4 hours or overnight.
  6. Scoop out generous portions onto serving bowls or cones. If desired, top with whipped cream, extra lemon zest, or chocolate chips. Enjoy!

Even those with limited cooking experience can craft their own delectable homemade ice cream by following this simple recipe.


No-Churn Recipe for Homemade Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream

Lemon poppy seed ice cream in a bowl

Photo Credit: The Frozen Fix

If you don’t have an ice cream machine, you might scroll right past typical ice cream recipes. But lo and behold: there’s another way to make homemade ice cream—all you need is a blender! No-churn ice cream is made easy with DIY ice cream mixes, like Hijinx. Simply blend your ingredients together, then freeze. An ice cream mix can cut down your prep time, and make ice cream making a little less intimidating. To make lemon poppy seed ice cream at home, you’ll just need the following:


  • 1 Hijinx packet
  • Lemon zest and lemon juice of 4 lemons
  • 2 tablespoons poppy seeds


  1. Blend one packet of HIJINX ice cream powder with 1.5 cups of hot water (or half & half), and lemon juice and zest for 3-4 minutes. Make sure HIJINX is fully dissolved.
  2. Let the mixture rest for 30 minutes on your counter. Stir in poppy seeds.
  3. Transfer to a freezer-safe container with an airtight lid
  4. Freeze for 3-6 hours. Enjoy!


Poppy Seeds: To Soak or Not to Soak?

Poppy seeds are a bit of a mystery in the kitchen. Some chefs swear by soaking them before use, while others skip this step entirely. Our homemade lemon poppy seed ice cream recipe doesn't call for soaking the seeds beforehand, but it's interesting to explore why some recipes do.


Why Soak Poppy Seeds?

Soaking poppy seeds is thought to not only make them easier to digest and bring out their flavor, but also unlock beneficial nutrients, like calcium and phosphorus.

  • Soaking: This method might enhance flavors and nutrient absorption but requires additional preparation time.
  • No-Soaking: Skipping this step simplifies the process without noticeably affecting taste or texture in most dishes, including our deliciously creamy lemon poppy seed ice cream.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to soak poppy seeds before using them comes down to individual choice and how much effort one is willing to put into prepping. But don't worry; no matter which route you take, rest assured knowing that your homemade dessert will still turn out absolutely delightful.


Creative Serving Suggestions For Your Homemade Ice Cream

After all the hard work of making your homemade lemon poppy seed ice cream, it's time to get creative with how you serve it. Sure, a simple scoop in a bowl or cone is always delightful, but why not take things up a notch?

Pairing Ideas

A custom ice cream sandwich is never a bad idea! One fantastic way to enjoy this ice cream is by sandwiching it between slices of pound cake. The buttery richness of the cake pairs beautifully with the tartness and crunchiness of our lemon poppy seed ice cream. To make this even more indulgent, drizzle some homemade blueberry syrup over top for an extra burst of fruit flavor, or grate some extra lemon zest for a bitter-sweet, colorful topper.

Innovative Ways to Serve Up Your Freshly Churned Ice Cream

If you're looking for something more adventurous, consider topping your scoops with unusual whipped cream spiked with Prosecco or Limoncello. This gives an exciting boozy twist that adults will love. If you need guidance on whipping up such toppings at home, you can add lemon curd, chocolate chips, sprinkles, or even make your own Prosecco Whipped Cream and Limoncello Whipped Cream.

As a side note, if you’d like to infuse limoncello directly into your ice cream, you can do so with Hijinx mix. Pour no more than 2 oz of your chosen alcohol directly into the blender with the rest of your ingredients—that’s it! It’s one of the easiest boozy ice cream recipes out there.


Alternative Ingredient Options for Vegan Ice Cream

A glass of milk and a bowl of almonds next to it

If you want to make your homemade ice cream healthier or more accessible, try swapping out traditional ingredients for alternatives. These substitutes can still result in deliciously creamy and flavorful scoops without sacrificing quality or taste.

Ingredient Alternatives for Dietary Restrictions

For those who are lactose intolerant or vegan, dairy-free milk options like almond, coconut, or soy milk can be used as a replacement base for homemade vegan ice cream. If you're trying to cut down on sugar, natural sweeteners such as honey or agave nectar could replace regular cane sugar.

Benefits & Challenges of Experimenting with New Ingredients

The upside of using different ingredients in homemade ice cream is that it permits everybody to appreciate the treat without worry. However, it's important to note that these substitutions may alter the texture and flavor slightly compared to traditional recipes.

A popular example involves using sweetened condensed milk instead of egg yolks. Cooked slowly until syrupy-thick, then combined with fresh lemon peel and juice, resulting in pleasantly tart scoops each time. This method not only simplifies the process but also makes it safer by eliminating raw eggs from the recipe. You can learn how this works by checking out this easy-to-follow no-churn ice cream recipe guide.


FAQs in Relation to Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream

Who makes lemon poppy seed ice cream?

Several brands make lemon poppy seed ice cream, including Tillamook and Ben & Jerry's. Many home cooks also create their own versions using ice cream machines or no-churn ice cream-making methods like ice cream mixes.

What do poppy seeds taste like?

Poppy seeds add a nutty and slightly sweet flavor to dishes. Nutritionally, they also provide a good amount of your daily calcium and phosphorus!

Why do you soak poppy seeds in milk?

Soaking poppy seeds in milk can help to soften them and release their flavor and nutritional benefits.



Fresh Lemons

Looking for a unique and delicious treat? Try making homemade lemon poppy seed ice cream with just a few ingredients. The tangy, fresh lemon juice and nutty flavor poppy seeds create an unforgettable profile that will leave your taste buds wanting more. Get creative with serving suggestions and try soaking your poppy seeds for an even richer flavor.

For those with dietary restrictions, don't worry - there are alternative ingredient options available that won't compromise on taste or quality. Want to learn more about the benefits of poppy seeds? Check out this article from Healthline.

Ready to start making your own lemon poppyseed ice cream? Grab some Hijinx ice cream mix and get blending!



Leave your comment