My Cart

Customized Ice Cream Cakes: How to Easily Make One & Where to Find Them

Customized ice cream cakes have become a popular choice for celebrating special occasions or simply satisfying your sweet tooth. Ice cream cakes offer so many possibilities in terms of flavors, textures, and designs, but when you customize your very own, you can truly set your imagination free. Read on for tips on making your very own, homemade custom ice cream cake! And if that feels too daunting for this particular birthday cake, keep reading for tips on where and how to customize and order ice cream cakes from your favorite local retailers.


Table of Contents:

  • Why Serve a Custom Ice Cream Cake?
  • Creating Your Own Customized Ice Cream Cake at Home
    • Softening and Layering the Ice Cream in Pans
    • Assembling Frozen Layers with Hot Fudge or Other Fillings
  • Exploring Flavor Combinations for Your Custom Ice Cream Cake
    • Classic Flavor Pairings That Never Disappoint
    • Unique Mixtures Worth Trying
  • Determining the Right Amount of Ice Cream
    • Factors Affecting the Amount of Ice Cream Required
  • Where to Buy a Custom Ice Cream Cake?
    • Walmart's Customizable Ice Cream Cakes
    • Baskin Robbins' Custom Ice Cream Cakes
  • Conclusion


Why Serve a Custom Ice Cream Cake?

3 flavored ice cream cake with cherries on top

Whether you’re a kid that wants something special in their birthday cake or an adult throwing a theme party that could use themed desserts, a customized ice cream cake can add an extra layer of fun to an occasion.

Ice cream cake can be a great option for those that don’t enjoy regular cake, as well as for guests that are gluten-intolerant.


Creating Your Own Customized Ice Cream Cake at Home

Birthday ice cream cake

Are you ready to impress your friends and family with a delicious, homemade custom ice cream cake? Look no further. We have the perfect step-by-step guide for creating an amazing dessert that will leave everyone asking for more. With endless possibilities in flavor combinations and decorations, you can let your creativity run wild.


Softening and Layering the Ice Cream in Pans
  1. To begin, choose two flavors of ice cream*, making sure they complement each other well. Remove them from the freezer to soften slightly (about 10 minutes).
  2. Meanwhile, line an 8-inch springform pan with plastic wrap or parchment paper. Once softened, spread one flavor evenly into the bottom of the pan using a spatula or spoon.
  3. Put the pan back in the cold while prepping for the next layer.
  4. In a large mixing bowl, combine heavy whipping cream (about 1 cup should suffice) along with powdered sugar (to taste) and vanilla extract (around half a teaspoon). Use an electric mixer or whisk by hand until stiff peaks form - this will be used as frosting later on.

*If you choose to make your own ice cream for this, check out this article on how to make easy homemade ice cream at home (with just a blender).


Assembling Frozen Layers with Hot Fudge or Other Fillings

1. Pull out your first frozen layer from the freezer once firm enough (approximately 30 minutes).

2. Add desired filling like hot fudge sauce over top - feel free to experiment with different options such as caramel drizzle, fruit preserves, or even crushed cookies and nuts. You can even place cake between layers like the Pioneer Woman!


3. Gently spread the second chosen softened ice cream atop the fillings, creating an even layer.

4. Return the assembled cake back into the freezer, allowing it to set completely (at least 4 hours).

5. Once your ice cream layers have hardened, remove the cake from its mold and place it on a serving platter. Frost the entire cake with the whipped cream mixture you prepared earlier, making sure to cover all sides evenly. To add some extra flair, consider using a piping bag for decorative swirls or borders.

6. Finally, garnish your custom ice cream cake with any desired toppings such as chocolate chips, sprinkles, or fresh fruit slices before returning it to the freezer until ready to serve (approximately 30 minutes).

Now sit back and enjoy your delicious masterpiece, knowing that not only did you create a unique dessert, but also saved money compared to store-bought options.


Exploring Flavor Combinations for Your Custom Ice Cream Cake

With endless possibilities when it comes to flavors, creating unique combinations can make your custom-made creation stand out even more. Consider mixing classics like chocolate and vanilla or experimenting with fruit-based options such as strawberry shortcake-inspired cakes.


Classic Flavor Pairings That Never Disappoint

If you're a fan of traditional ice cream cake flavors, there are plenty of classic combinations that will always be crowd-pleasers. Some tried-and-true favorites include:


Unique Flavor Combinations Worth Trying

When you create your own ice cream cake with homemade ice cream, you can create ANY combo you want. And when you make homemade ice cream with an ice cream mix like Hijinx—that you simply blend and freeze with your favorite ingredients—you can ultra-personalize your flavors and colors to whatever your heart desires. If you're looking to step outside the box and try something new, consider these innovative flavors that you can mix-and-match for a multi-flavor cake:

    • Lemon Raspberry Ripple: A refreshing blend of tangy lemon ice cream swirled with sweet raspberry sauce.
    • Espresso Martini: Your favorite cocktail can become a decadent, coffee-forward element of your cake. And yes, it can have real ABV. 
    • Peanut Butter Cup S'mores: This decadent combination features peanut butter cup ice cream layered between graham cracker crumbs and marshmallow fluff.
    • Cinnamon Roll: Cinnamon-y, buttery–all the things you want in a dessert, transformed into a creamy, frozen treat.
    • Bourbon Pecan Pie: A rich bourbon-flavored ice cream filled with chunks of pecan pie pieces.
  • PB&J: What’s better for a celebratory cake than nostalgia? PB&J is the perfect throwback flavor for a graduation party or birthday.
    • Tropical Mango Coconut: A fruity, refreshing mix of mango sorbet and coconut ice cream.

    To learn more about how to create easy, custom ice cream with Hijinx, click here.


    Determining the Right Amount of Ice Cream

    When making a homemade ice cream cake, it's important to know how much ice cream is needed per person. For an 8-inch cake, two 1.5-quart containers should provide enough ice cream for 12 to 16 servings. However, several factors can affect the amount of ice cream required.


    Factors Affecting the Amount of Ice Cream Required
    • Guest preferences: Consider your guests' taste preferences and dietary restrictions when deciding on flavors and quantities.
    • Cake size: The size and shape of your cake will determine how much ice cream you need. Larger cakes require more ice cream to fill out their dimensions properly.
    • Serving sizes: If you're serving other desserts alongside your ice cream cake, consider reducing portion sizes accordingly so everyone has room to try everything.


    Where to Buy a Custom Ice Cream Cake?

    Bakery with ice cream cakes

    When time-saving and accessibility is key, purchasing an ice cream cake might just be the move. If making your ice cream cake from scratch isn’t for you, try one of the awesome retailers that will customize an ice cream cake for your special occasion. Though the ice cream flavors may not be as unique as making them at home, you can still pick many elements of your cake without having to do it yourself!


    Walmart's Custom Ice Cream Cakes

    If you're looking for a delicious and affordable custom ice cream cake, look no further than Walmart. They offer a wide variety of customizable options online when ordering their scrumptious treats. With various designs, flavors, toppings, icings, candles, and more to choose from, you can create the perfect ice cream cake that suits your taste buds and budget.

    Some popular design choices available at Walmart include:

    • Character cakes: Featuring beloved characters from movies or TV shows like Disney Princesses or Marvel superheroes.
    • Sports-themed cakes: Showcasing team logos or sports equipment for avid fans.
    • Celebration cakes: Perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, or graduations with festive decorations and personalized messages.
    • Holiday-themed cakes: Celebrate special occasions like Christmas or Halloween with themed designs and colors.

    Choose from various types of icings, such as buttercream frosting or whipped topping, to customize your cake. The possibilities are endless. To order your own customized ice cream cake from Walmart is simple. Just follow these easy steps below:

    1. Browse through the selection of pre-designed templates on their website by clicking this link: https://www.walmart.com/browse/food/custom-cakes/976759_1228023.
    2. Select the design that is perfect for your occasion or theme.
    3. Select your preferred cake flavor, icing type, and any additional customization options such as personalized messages or decorations.
    4. Add the custom ice cream cake to your cart and proceed with checkout. Be sure to provide a pick-up date for when you'd like to collect it from your local Walmart store.


    Baskin Robbins’ Custom Ice Cream Cakes

    When it comes to ice cream cakes, Baskin Robbins is known for their wide array of customized selections tailored to customer preferences. They offer numerous options, including fruit toppings, icing sugars, chocolates, candles, coconut, enveloping flying balloons, flowers, and crunchy nuts, among others. Let's dive into some popular design choices and how you can order a custom-designed offering from Baskin Robbins.

    Some popular design choices include:

    • Fudge Crunch Cake: A delightful combination of chocolate fudge and crunchies layered between two flavors of your choice.
    • Polar Pizza: An innovative twist on the traditional cake featuring a cookie or brownie crust topped with ice cream and various toppings like candy pieces or sprinkles.
    • Celebration Cookie Cake: A giant chocolate chip cookie sandwich filled with your favorite ice cream flavor and decorated as per your liking.
    • Rolled Fondant Cakes: These elegant creations are covered in smooth fondant that can be customized with colors and designs to match any theme or occasion.

    In addition to these popular options, Baskin Robbins also offers seasonal specials such as holiday-themed cakes during Christmas time or pumpkin-flavored treats during Halloween. With so many choices available at Baskin Robbins, you're sure to find the perfect custom ice cream cake for any event.

    To order your very own personalized creation from Baskin Robbins, follow these simple steps:

    1. Visit the Baskin Robbins website and click on the 'Order Online' tab.
    2. Select your preferred store location for pickup or delivery.
    3. Browse through their extensive menu of ice cream cakes and choose a base design that suits your taste.
    4. Once you've decided on a cake, personalize it with your preferred flavors, fillings, toppings and decorations - plus add special messages to make it truly unique. You can even add personalized messages to make it extra special.
    5. Complete the checkout process by providing necessary details such as contact information and payment method. Make sure to place your order at least 24 hours in advance to ensure timely preparation of your custom creation.



    Birthday ice cream cake

    Creating customized ice cream cakes at home is a fun and delicious way to impress your guests, build your own birthday cake, or satisfy your sweet tooth. By determining the right amount of ice cream, assembling with your favorite flavors, and exploring different flavor combinations, you can create a masterpiece that everyone will love.

    If you're short on time or prefer to leave it to the professionals, Walmart and Baskin Robbins offer customizable options tailored according to customer preferences. Still, nothing beats the feeling of concocting a personalized frozen treat from scratch.

    Ready to start making your own customized ice cream cake? Check out Hijinx Ice Cream to create your very own homemade ice cream flavors for your custom cake!



    Leave your comment